6 Plant-Based Pumpkin Pie Recipes - Lani Muelrath | Mindful, Active, Vegan Living (2024)

Photo courtesy Cathy Fisher at Straight Up Food

6 Plant-Based Pumpkin Pie Recipes

Having made many a plant-based pumpkin pie in my time, at this time of year I find myself again on the lookout for a new variation on the pumpkin pie theme. Oddly enough, as a kid I couldn’t stand pumpkin pie – go figure! It was only when I started creating the plant-based pumpkin pie options that I really took to this dessert.

I started my search this timeat the place I always turn to when looking for low-fat plant-exclusive recipes: My friend Susan Voison at the Fat Free Vegan Blog. Susan’s pictures are among my favorite food pics on the web. I don’t know how she does it. but her snapshots of even simple fare screams designer food and always get me fired up about making whatever it is she has created. This time was no different.

Then I saw that Cathy Fisher of Straight Up Food has a new pumpkin pie recipe, as does Dreena Burton over at Plant-Powered Kitchen. This gave me five recipes to bring to your attention in short order. Soon a sixth was brought to my attention, which I’ve added for you as well.

And I thought, why not share with you the benefit of my search?Though none of these recipes have animal products, true to the plant-based title on this article, I would not venture to claim that they are all ‘health food’ or even all ‘healthy options’. They floated to the top of the list, each with varying degrees of processed or unprocessed ingredients.

Choose The Plant-Based Pumpkin Pie That Works For You!

Each of the recipes below has a place. So rather than choose for you, I thought I’d share with you these six plant-based pumpkin pie options and let you choose which works best for you. I’ve provided a snapshot of each for you along with links to the appropriate website so you can take a look at the recipe and decide what you might like to make.

On the plant-based adventure, there are many stages and many venues for presenting plant-based food for family, friends, and even yourself. Having more options than either traditional high-fat animal product or orange pile-of-twigs-and-bark – opposite ends of the spectrum – I offer you these ideas in the hopes that it helps you find a best match for what you can use during the holidays.

Besides, this way I have them all linked in one place for future reference. Thinking!

1) Double Layer Pumpkin Cheesecake

Direct from Susan’s Fat Free Vegan Blog, Susan admittedly says

“This is not a fat-free recipe” disclaimer here. Geez, what was I thinking when I named this blog!

Double-Layer Pumpkin Cheesecake is undoubtedly the richest of the six recipes featured here today. It has a commercial graham cracker crust as well as a layer of highly processed tofu cream cheese. It is also argueably the one most sure to please at the omnivorous holiday table where everyone else maystill quizzically respond “vege-what?” when then discover your dietary persuasion. I’ve made this recipe for dinner guests without even mentioning what’s on the ingredients list and it was a huge hit. No need to knock people over the head with “tofu this” and “egg-free that” unless they express interest. Which, by the way, they will do with this recipe.

You can find the recipe for Susan’s Double Layer Pumpkin Cheesecake here.

2) Bryanna’s Vegan Pumpkin Pie

The notes attached to this recipe read:

“I don’t like pumpkin pie made with tofu-no one ever suspects this one doesn’t have eggs. One caution-MAKE THIS THE DAY BEFORE SERVING. It’s needs a day to set really well, I find. This is a spicy filling.”

This particular recipe uses a pre-made pie crust, which you can of course get around by making your own. Just like the Double Layer recipe above, it calls for a lot of extra sweet in the form of sugar. This one I haven’t made, but it looks like it might taste ‘traditional pumpkin pie’ if that is what you are looking for.

You can find the recipe here: Bryanna’s Vegan Pumpkin Pie.

3) Impossible (crustless) Vegan Pumpkin Pie

The operative term here is ‘crustless’. Still lots of sugar, but no added oil or dairy products to make this custard-like, crustless pumpkin pie. Susan’s notes:

Though the inside is more like a custard than a regular pumpkin pie, a slight crust formed along the bottom and sides of the pan, so you can actually pick up a slice of this pie and eat it like a piece of pizza. But it’s dangerously addictive, as shown by the fact that my husband ate about 6 pieces of it yesterday!

Click here for the recipe for Impossible (crustless) Vegan Pumpkin Pie.

4) Great Pumpkin Pie (vegan; soy and gluten free)

From there it was on to Dreena Burton’s Plant-Powered Food where I found this little gem. Dreena says:

Wait… Do we really need another pumpkin pie recipe? Why is this one special?

Indeed, there is no shortage of pumpkin pie recipes – even vegan. A quick google search will confirm that. I’ve baked my fair share of pumpkin pies. Crusts made with graham or cookie crusts, fillings with silken tofu or chocolate, the list goes on.

But, ever since creating the Pumpkin Pie Custards in Let Them Eat Vegan, I’ve wanted to somehow transform the recipe into a pie! It needed tweaks, to thicken and stabilize. Plus, I wanted to develop a crust that was (1) wholesome and (2) EASY (we need some breaks during the holidays)!

That’s right – with this one you get both filling (maply syrup is the sweetener) and the crust (rolled oats, dates, and almond butter….yums!)

For Dreena’s Great Pumpkin Pie recipe, click here.

5) Pumpkin Pie ‘Straight Up’

Arguably the healthiest recipe in this collection, this one comes to you from Cathy Fisher’s blog Straight Up Food. Cathy specializes in recipes that are oil, sugar, and salt (“no S.O.S.” free. You’ve got to agree with me this one looks absolutely gorgeous! Cathy says:

“Serve this at any holiday table, and people will ask for more. The filling is sweetened with dates and thickened with a bit of oat flour. The pecan-date crust is like a sweet, crumbly cookie. Grab a fork and dig in!”

To download Cathy’s Pumpkin Pie Straight Up recipe, click here.

6)Pumpkin Pie in the Free World

The fat free, gluten free, soy free world, that is.

I was just about to click “publish” on this pie extravaganza piece when Maria from Plant-based Slow Motion Miracle saw my conversations on facebook about same and jumped in with this contribution.

Like Fisher’s Straight Up recipe, Maria contributes a from-scratch crust with oats, pecans, and apple sauce. Plus Maria’s story is so unique and inspiring – how she is successfully managing MS, Fibromyalgia and mild Cerebral Palsy with a plant-based diet –it is worthy of your attention.

You will find Moonwatcher’s Free World Pumpkin Pie recipe here.

Please share in comments below which recipe catches your attention – and why!Haveyou madeone of them, or do you plan to?

6 Plant-Based Pumpkin Pie Recipes - Lani Muelrath | Mindful, Active, Vegan Living (8)

6 Plant-Based Pumpkin Pie Recipes - Lani Muelrath | Mindful, Active, Vegan Living (2024)


Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated:

Views: 6549

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.